A perfect tadka announces itself through colour changes, controlled sizzling, and a rounded aroma—when these cues align, the tempering is ready to be poured without hesitation. Recognising the visual, auditory and aromatic cues that signal a good tadka from a great tadka distinguishes between the two.
A tadka, or tempering, is the smallest step in Indian cooking, but one of the most significant ways to flavour your food. A few spices cooked in hot oil can enhance or greatly diminish the flavour of your food if you time them incorrectly. When it comes to a tadka, since the process is relatively short, the cook relies more on their senses than the measurements of ingredients they've used.
A tadka starts before a spice hits the pan; it must be in a hot enough oil or ghee that it immediately activates the flavour of the spices, but not so hot that the spices will burn. In visual terms, the hot fat will shimmer and move about the sauté pan with relative ease. The aroma of the ghee, once it reaches a hot enough temperature, will also be an attestation to its readiness, with the ghee's nutty warmth aroma, while the oil is sharper or cleaner. If spices are placed into the fat and sink without making any noise, the oil/ghee is too cool; if the spices smoke immediately when placed in hot oil/ghee, they are also at a temperature too high.
By using colour as a cue, spices send clear signals regarding their level of development. Mustard seeds will go from matte to shiny as the seeds pop; cumin seeds will turn from light brown to dark brown while remaining whole. Garlic will go from white to pale gold as it cooks, but never dark brown. Curry leaves will get a little darker in colour and become crispy at the edges. All of these changes take place very quickly, and after reaching a certain point on the colour scale, the spice will have developed bitterness.
Another telltale sign of an ideal tadka is the sound it produces while cooking. Healthy tadkas make a sharp sound and sizzle evenly with no erratic movement. Mustard seeds will crackle in sync and regularly, cumin will hiss quietly, and when adding fresh spices such as curry leaves, the sound produced by the direct transfer of moisture into hot oil is very loud. When the sizzle changes from sharp and loud to continuous and softer, this indicates that the moisture has evaporated and all of the flavours have been released.
Aroma is the last indicator of how well you have developed your tadka. Whenever you smell unheated or raw spices, they will smell flat and dusty, but once you heat the spices, you can smell their newly developed roundedness and richness. Cumin's aroma will have changed from a grassy aroma into a nutty aroma; garlic's aroma will have changed from an irritating bite to a sweet flavour; and hing's flavour has been mellowed into savoury depth. The peak of aroma development is just before the smoke begins to rise; therefore, this is the ideal time to remove the tadka from the cooking process.
The sequence of how tadka is made can drastically change the taste of the dish. Whole seed spices (cumin, mustard, fenugreek, etc.) are typically added first when making tadka, followed by aromatics (onion, garlic, ginger, etc.), and last of all, the delicate herbs and powdered spices (coriander, turmeric, chilli, etc.).
Burnt tadka will always be very obvious. The oil will be smoking excessively, the spices will be burnt to black ash, and they will smell burnt rather than warm. If you've burnt tadka, nothing you can do afterwards (including adding more oil in order to dilute it) can fix it completely. Burnt tadka is capable of ruining an entire dish, so it is more important to pay close attention at this stage rather than trying to multitask.
A well-prepared tadka is to be poured onto your food as soon as it is finished cooking. Leaving tadka in a hot pan for even a few seconds can put it past its ideal point. The sizzling sound the tadka makes when you pour it over a blessed variety of dal, curds or vegetables is not only impressive, but it also shows you that the tadka has been cooked properly and is at the correct time to add it to your dish.
Through learning how to create perfect tadka, cooks develop a connection to their cooking instincts rather than following strict guidelines. With continued practice, cooks learn how to anticipate the next step in creating a great tadka rather than reacting.
A perfectly executed tadka has three components at the same time. When these components align - a dish that has the proper colour, the proper sound and the proper aroma - there is only one mistake to make: the mistake of hesitation. As cooks begin to understand these components of creating a great tadka, they can move from a stage of fear of making a mistake with tadka to a stage of assurance that their tadka will become the finishing touch that completes the dish.